'Baltimoreed' - Compared to many other rifle actions, the Krag ejector is pretty anemic. However, with brisk Bolt movement to the rear, it normally gets the job done.

It does sound like your 'ejector-pin' has been replaced. A loose and undersized pin would probably compromise ejector function. (I am attaching a photo of normal parts for your reference).

My suggestion is to lay the barreled/receiver, left-side down, on a table or bench, leaving the pin-hole overhanging the table edge. Lightly tap, repeatedly, on the ejector (body) in its recess, with a brass punch & plastic mallet. Check to see if the pin becomes partially exposed and can be gripped with needle-nose pliers.

If all else fails, I would attempt to 'center-punch' the tip of the pin and then drill a small shallow hole into the pin. I would then insert a drill shank into the hole and slightly 'lever' it to provide some friction and draw the pin out.

p.s. If you have a strong small magnet, use it to try and 'draw' the end of the pin out, while slowly wiggling the ejector side to side. (worth a try)!

---