Page Index Toggle Pages: [1] 2  Send TopicPrint
 10 Interesting failure NRA-UK report (Read 13905 times)
butlersrangers
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 6330
Location: Michigan Bi-Peninsular&Proud
Joined: Oct 7th, 2009
Interesting failure NRA-UK report
May 10th, 2015 at 11:19pm
Print Post  
This 'catastrophic failure' of a Norwegian Krag occurred in Great Britain at a practice match in the Spring of 2014. It was investigated by the NRA-UK. The 23 page report was posted today on the Military Surplus Collectors Forum (under Krag rifles).

The Norwegian Krag action (#32513) was of 1897 Steyr vintage. A Norwegian match barrel was installed circa 1950 and the rifle has been in routine use and well maintained. Nicks and alterations to the action receiver ring and threads led to suspicions regarding the installer's competency.

The 'home loads' (reloads) used Norma brass, 140 grain bullet, and 34.4 grains of Accurate 2520. (This load appears just above a 'starting load' and well below Max. in one Accurate Arms table, I found). The rifle came apart on the fourth shot. The 'shooter', a neighboring 'shooter', and a spectator were injured and required hospital treatment (surgery for two and OP for the third).

The NRA-UK report noted 'grossly deformed necks' on some of the 'homeloads', which indicated improper setting of equipment. They displayed one of the fired cases, which looked normal. However, IMHO, the photo of a deformed loaded case in a Wilson gauge, appears to show a possible head-space problem, caused by excessive case length or poor adjustments. (I wish the report gave more attention to the dimensions of the fired cases and case length of the deformed necks).

Some parts of the destroyed Krag-Jogensen could not be found. The NRA-UK found no clear definite cause and called it: "A single overload event". If I understand the report's conclusion correctly, they attributed the failure to an excessive load or latent defect in the re-barreled rifle.

(The excessive pressure could have been an under-load detonation, an excessive pressure over-load, or something related to the 'funny' case necks).
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
butlersrangers
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 6330
Location: Michigan Bi-Peninsular&Proud
Joined: Oct 7th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #1 - May 10th, 2015 at 11:20pm
Print Post  
Hey, that single bolt lug held and we have visual evidence that Norwegian Krags have left-hand barrel threads. I bet our shooters can come up with a better analysis of this accident than the 'Brits' did!

(Those distorted case necks must cause a problem with neck-bullet tension. Deformed case neck pics):
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
cdagnese
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 75
Joined: Oct 15th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #2 - May 11th, 2015 at 1:28am
Print Post  
Detonation is a very plausible cause here. Fast powders and low case density are a dangerous thing in rifle calibers.  Too large a diameter of projectile could also cause this.

A note about the Brits.  There's a story going around the FAA about the Bits.  They were looking for  a way to test the windshields for their high speed trains.  They asked the FAA to borrow the "Chicken Gun" that we use to test aircraft windshields.  It actually shoots chicken carcasses at the windshield. Well, the Brits, using the Chicken Gun, busted just about every windshield the had and sent a report to the FAA for review.  They couldn't understand why all their windshields were breaking.  After the FAA read the report, they sent the Brits one recommendation.  "Thaw out the chickens before you shoot them".
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
Parashooter
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Kragmudgeon

Posts: 514
Location: Connecticut
Joined: Feb 4th, 2010
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #3 - May 11th, 2015 at 4:50am
Print Post  
butlersrangers wrote on May 10th, 2015 at 11:20pm:
Hey, that single bolt lug held . . .


Single lug? (The usual Norwegian arrangement has two, no?)
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
butlersrangers
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 6330
Location: Michigan Bi-Peninsular&Proud
Joined: Oct 7th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #4 - May 11th, 2015 at 6:53am
Print Post  
Yeh, one forward lug, a bolt guide rib (fitted to make contact with the receiver, unlike U.S. Krag bolts), and the bolt handle root.

I guess my point was: The bolt was not the weakest link.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
Bernt
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 7
Joined: May 5th, 2014
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #5 - May 11th, 2015 at 7:48am
Print Post  
Hi guys, just posted this on the Milsurp forum. I'll post it here as well. Just some background info from Norway. Krags rarely blow up, but when they do, this is the usual pattern.

In the 1970's the norwegian Krag ammo was downloaded to a preassure of 2800 BAR (from originally 3100 BAR). The reason was that some Krags started to develop cracks. These rifles had shot maybe tens of thousands of shots with metal fatiqe on certain spots as a result. The cracks are usually found in the lower right corner, near where the locking lug engages the receiver, and in the upper left corner by the extractors supportspring. On Kongsberg Krags these corners are sharp (90`) , while the Steyr Krags have rounded corners, and are considered stronger. The sharp corner is a more likely starting point for a crack than a rounded corner.

As they say: "Allways have a competent gunsmith check any old gun before you fire it".

Faulty ammo can blow up any rifle. And this Krag blew up in the usual pattern. The cut for the extractor is the weakest spot around the case, and when it burst, this is where the gasses go. The extractor and top of the receiver ring is blown off as a result.

This link to a norwegian forum shows a Krag that were blown up on purpose. The guy loaded a full case of N110 or N340, tied it to a tree, and pulled the trigger with a string.
It looks pretty much identical to the UK incident.

(You need to Login to view media files and links)
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
madsenshooter
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 1079
Joined: Sep 10th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #6 - May 13th, 2015 at 6:39pm
Print Post  
It appears the fellow needs some reloading lessons.  SEE is a possibility.  Low charge, long and perhaps rough throat.  The bullet stops for a millisecond, the powder keeps burning and pressure goes through the roof.  6.5 Swedish is notorious for this, not just in Krags, guys have blown up more than one Swedish Mauser with loads that were meant to take it easy on the old gun.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
FredC
KCA Official Member
***
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 759
Location: Dewees, Texas
Joined: May 31st, 2013
Gender: Male
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #7 - May 14th, 2015 at 1:41pm
Print Post  
Looking at both fotos of the blown up guns I am wondering if the threaded ring did not fail first. Maybe the relatively soft barrel swelled splitting the ring and as the barrel moved forward after the ring split, the extractor pulled the rim till the rim/case failed. The American Krag is not particularly weak in the area of the cut. I just finished rebarreling an action and I was impressed with the strength in that area. The Brits may have been on to something when they mentioned the marks on the receiver. A pipe wrench applied there during rebarreling would make deep marks that would concentrate stress and drastically weaken it.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
butlersrangers
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 6330
Location: Michigan Bi-Peninsular&Proud
Joined: Oct 7th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #8 - May 14th, 2015 at 4:11pm
Print Post  
I'm not an Engineer or Metallurgist, but IMHO, this mischief was caused by extreme high pressure gases (due to over-load, under-load detonation, bullet/throat problem, compromised cartridge case???) blowing out the case head and allowing the gases to enter the action. (Metal fatigue or flaws may have contributed, but, probably not necessary or root cause).

When rimless cartridges and their rifle actions 'blow up', they look kind of similar, with top of receiver ring and extractor gone, and other wreckage somewhat restrained by wood.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
kragluver
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 48
Joined: Dec 6th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #9 - May 18th, 2015 at 12:09am
Print Post  
Just to set the record straight, small charges of SLOW powder in rifle cases are what cause SEE. Fast powders should be used for reduced loads (e.g., 5744, 2400 or 4759, etc.). There is a lot of misinformation out there about SEE. Anyone interested should read Firearm Pressure Factors.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
reincarnated
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 562
Joined: Mar 11th, 2012
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #10 - May 18th, 2015 at 2:31am
Print Post  
At risk of appearing totally out to lunch, what is SEE?
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
butlersrangers
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 6330
Location: Michigan Bi-Peninsular&Proud
Joined: Oct 7th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #11 - May 18th, 2015 at 4:13am
Print Post  
SEE = Secondary Explosive Effect (aka - Detonation).

If I understand the basic theory correctly, there is a partial burn of the powder charge, the projectile moves forward and hesitates or hangs up, a pressure wave and intense heat occur, the remainder of the powder charge explodes creating amazing rifle shattering pressures.

I believe the most accepted culprit loads are under-loads of slow burning propellants.

(FWIW - The UK 6.5 X 55mm Norwegian Krag rifle mishap involved a load using 140 grain bullet and 34.4 grains Accurate 2520. I don't think Accurate 2520 is a slow burning propellant and 34.4 grains is a bit above the 'starting load' in some tables).
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
reincarnated
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 562
Joined: Mar 11th, 2012
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #12 - May 18th, 2015 at 6:23am
Print Post  
Thanks, BR.  My burn rate list says Accurate 2520 is just a smidge slower than IMR-4064 and a good bit faster than IMR-4320.  Jacketed bullet loads in the 34 to 36 grain load range have been in use since the 1930s for US Krags and the '06.  My guess is that something else was amiss.  Those case necks did not look kosher.  Bullets for a Carcano?  IIRC, those run .266-.268 and come in boxes that say 6.5 mm.

That Lee Navy makes me want to cry.  I spent the better part of 3 years trying to find a good one at a price I could afford.  I quit looking when those accidents appeared on the net.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
kragluver
KCA Forum Member
*
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 48
Joined: Dec 6th, 2009
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #13 - May 18th, 2015 at 12:09pm
Print Post  
"Slow" is relative here. The research that was done back in the '60's would indicate a SEE event can occur for powders at or slower than 3031. I wouldn't have used any of the powders mentioned here for reduced loads. There are powders specifically intended for such loads.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
FredC
KCA Official Member
***
Offline


Krag Enthusiast!

Posts: 759
Location: Dewees, Texas
Joined: May 31st, 2013
Gender: Male
Re: Interesting failure NRA-UK report
Reply #14 - May 19th, 2015 at 1:35pm
Print Post  
Butlersrangers, that Swiss blowup kind of messes with my theory. It would be interesting to see a high speed video of each of the blow ups. After the high pressure event they are not coming apart as I would have expected.
Just a couple of notes on the US Krag I just rebarreled:
The bolt did have a lot of over travel with no case in the chamber. If this is the same with a 6.5X55, the bolt could follow a severely resized case way to far.
The chamber was .010 to .012 larger than an unfired case.  Not sure if this was from an oversize reamer when the gun was first assembled or if the barrel swelled with use over the last century. If it swelled with the relatively low pressure loads then the  barrel steel is fairly soft.
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
Page Index Toggle Pages: [1] 2 
Send TopicPrint